Reforming Accreditation To Strengthen Higher Education
This Executive Order directs the Department of Education and the Justice Department to reform how U.S. higher-education accreditors are overseen and recognized. It responds to concerns that some accreditors have prioritized diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) requirements or other governance matters over student outcomes, allowed low-value programs to access federal student aid, or imposed standards that conflict with state law. The order instructs agency officials to hold accreditors accountable for unlawful discrimination, promote outcome-focused accreditation, open the door to new accreditors and alternative quality-assurance models, and streamline recognition and review processes. If implemented, the order could change what colleges and professional schools must demonstrate to retain accreditation (and thus access to federal student aid), encourage new or alternative accrediting pathways, and increase federal scrutiny of accreditation standards—especially any that reference race, ethnicity, or sex. It may trigger reviews or enforcement actions against specific accreditors for alleged unlawful DEI-related standards, and could shift accreditation emphasis toward measurable student outcomes, cost/value, and “intellectual diversity.”
Key Points
- 1Holds accreditors accountable for unlawful actions: The Secretary of Education may deny, monitor, suspend, or terminate recognition of accreditors who fail to meet recognition criteria or who require institutions to engage in unlawful discrimination under the cover of DEI standards.
- 2Directs investigations of specific professional accreditors: The Attorney General and Secretary of Education are instructed to investigate and consider suspending or terminating federal recognition of the ABA’s law-school accreditor (the Council), the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME), and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) if they advance unlawful discriminatory standards.
- 3Establishes "student-oriented" accreditation principles: Accreditation should emphasize high-quality, high-value programs, use program-level student outcomes data to drive improvement, reduce barriers to credential completion and innovation, protect intellectual diversity among faculty, avoid forcing institutions to violate state law, and prevent credential inflation (unnecessary added credentials/costs).
- 4Opens recognition to new accreditors and experimental pathways: The order directs the Department to resume recognizing new accreditors to increase competition and to launch an HEA experimental-site project (under Higher Education Act section 487A(b)) to test flexible, streamlined quality-assurance pathways for institutions that demonstrate value and outcomes.
- 5Streamlines and increases transparency of recognition: The Department is ordered to provide accreditors with Office for Civil Rights findings of noncompliance under Title VI and Title IX, speed up and modernize the accreditor recognition review process, make it easier for institutions to change accreditors, and update the Accreditation Handbook to reduce burdens.